Cost daycare: Compare mortgage, refinance, insurance, CD rates

Опубликовано: October 1, 2023 в 6:42 pm

Автор:

Категории: Miscellaneous

Child Care Cost Burden* | County Health Rankings & Roadmaps

Data Source

The Living Wage Calculator; Small Area Income and Poverty Estimates

The Living Wage calculator estimates the cost of living in your community or region based on typical expenses. The tool helps individuals, communities, and employers determine a local wage rate that allows residents to meet minimum standards of living.

The US Census Bureau, with support from other federal agencies, created the Small Area Income and Poverty Estimates (SAIPE) program to provide more current estimates of selected income and poverty statistics than those from the most recent decennial census. The main objective of this program is to provide updated estimates of income and poverty statistics for the administration of federal programs and the allocation of federal funds to local jurisdictions. These estimates combine data from administrative records, intercensal population estimates, and the decennial census, along with direct estimates from the American Community Survey, to provide consistent and reliable single-year estimates. These model-based single-year estimates are more reflective of current conditions than multi-year survey estimates. At the county level, SAIPE provides estimates on children ages 5-17 in families in poverty, children under age 18 in poverty, all people in poverty, and median household income. Estimates are created for school districts, counties, and states.

Website to download data
For more detailed methodological information

Key Measure Methods

Child Care Cost Burden is a percentage

Child Care Cost Burden is the cost of child care for a household with two children as a percent of median household income.

Child Care Cost Burden cannot be compared across state lines

Childcare cost data are based on market-rate surveys reported separately by state, published in different years. Some states only report state- or region-level estimates, and thus require county-level imputation. Due to this, states may differ in the extent to which estimates are modeled vs. observed.

Measure limitations

Child care costs as a percentage of median income in a county is not fully representative of the cost burden of child care in a county, as half of the households have a lower income and thus child care would constitute an even higher percentage of their income. Similarly, this measure is not representative of the cost of child care for families with more than two children, or with infant children.  

Finally, the quality of child care is most important in terms of positive impacts on children’s development, and the measure of Child Care Cost Burden does not reflect the quality of available care. 

Numerator

Child care cost data provided by the Living Wage Calculator.

Denominator

Median household income data calculated from the Small Area Income and Poverty Estimates.

Can This Measure Be Used to Track Progress

The estimate of child care costs have been adjusted to reflect inflation and should not be compared to past years.

Finding More Data

Disaggregation means breaking data down into smaller, meaningful subgroups. Disaggregated data are often broken down by characteristics of people or where they live. Disaggregated data can reveal inequalities that are otherwise hidden. These data can be disaggregated by:

  • Age
  • Race
  • Subcounty Area

The Living Wage Calculator is the source for the household expenses used in the Child Care Cost Burden measure. Child care expenses by county are available at https://livingwage.mit.edu/.

Child Care Aware of America (CCAoA) https://www.childcareaware.org/our-issues/research/ccdc/: offers summary data for most US states and the Child Care Data Center (CCDC) provides state and county-level data about child care affordability, accessibility, and environmental risk within six pilot states (Illinois, Minnesota, Missouri, Oregon, Washington, and Wisconsin).

The Economic Policy Institute (EPI) https://www.epi.org/child-care-costs-in-the-united-states/: offers an interactive tool to examine the costs of child care in each state, and the cost of child care as a percentage of multiple income levels.

The Diversity Data Kids – Child Opportunity Index includes a summary measure of early childhood education alongside other components of place-based opportunity for children.

The County Health Rankings measure of Child Care Centers provides added context for understanding child care opportunities in your community.

References

1 Magnuson, Katherine, and Jane Waldfogel. “Delivering High-Quality Early Childhood Education and Care to Low-Income Children: How Well Is the U.S. Doing?” In An Equal Start?: Providing Quality Early Education and Care for Disadvantaged Children, edited by Jane Waldfogel, Ludovica Gambaro, and Kitty Stewart, 1st ed., 193–218. Bristol University Press, 2014. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt9qgznh.14. 

2 Lyonette, C., Kaufman, G., and Crompton, R. “‘We Both Need to Work’: Maternal Employment, Childcare and Health Care in Britain and the USA.” Work, Employment and Society 25, no. 1 (March 1, 2011): 34–50. https://doi. org/10.1177/0950017010389243. 

3 Gould, E. and Cooke, T. 2015. High quality child care is out of reach for working families. Economic Policy Institute. Issue Brief #404. https://www.epi.org/publication/child-care-affordability/ 

4 Child Care and Development Fund (CCDF) Program, A Proposed Rule by the Health and Human Services Department on 12/24/2015. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2015/12/24/2015-31883/child-care-and-development-fund-ccdf-program 

5 Mattingly, M. J., Schaefer, A. P., and Carson, J. A. 2016. Child Care Costs Exceed 10 Percent of Family Income for One in Four Families. The Carsey School of Public Policy at the Scholars’ Repository. 288. 

https://scholars.unh.edu/carsey/288 

6 Glasmeier, Amy K. 2020. Living Wage Calculator. Massachusetts Institute of Technology. livingwage.mit.edu. 

 

 

Child care expenses are ‘crippling,’ say Boston.com readers

Readers Say

Many readers support Sen.

Elizabeth Warren’s Childcare for Every Community Act.

Amy McCoy serves lunch to preschoolers at her Forever Young Daycare facility, Monday, Oct. 25, 2021, in Mountlake Terrace, Wash. The Associated Press

By Kristi Palma

Boston.com readers are stressed over child care costs, according to a Boston.com poll. A recently filed federal proposal led by Sen. Elizabeth Warren, called the Child Care for Every Community Act, could provide Bay State families relief.

  • What is the most picturesque small town in Massachusetts?

  • ‘Why should I have to pay more to commute?’: Readers say state should steer clear of congestion pricing

The proposal would fully subsidize child care expenses for families making less than 75% of their state’s median income and cap child care expenses for high-income families at 7% of their household income.

A Mass. family making $130,125 would pay $200 a month under the proposal, according to Warren, rather than the current average of $3,128 a month. More than half of American families would pay just $10 a day for child care.

Advertisement:

Of the 291 readers who responded to our poll, 71% pay for daycare, 11% pay for pre-K, and 7% pay for a nanny. Most said the costs were too high for their family.

“It’s inconceivable that the cost of child care is nearly equal to one parent’s monthly salary (and that salaries for child care workers are so low, but that’s another issue),” wrote A.R. from Ashland. “My partner and I both have good, well-paying jobs, but once we enroll in child care, we will have little to no disposable income, and our salaries will go entirely to our mortgage, utilities, and child care.”

What type of child care do you use?

Daycare

“We pay $2,000 per month per child and $3,000 per month for our infant,” wrote Michael from Burlington. “Two kids and one infant come to $7,000 per month that we are paying. It is outrageous and most days it doesn’t seem worth working for.”

Many Boston.com readers support Warren’s proposal. Ahead, Boston.com readers share their thoughts about it.

Responses have been lightly edited for clarity.

‘It would drastically help my family’

“I work from home so I don’t have any other option but to put my 18-month-old into daycare so I can work to pay for daycare and keep our health insurance for the family. With this proposal, it would drastically help my family be able to pay off other debts and live more comfortably financially.” — Kerry from Billerica, who pays $2,050 per month

Advertisement:

“Warren’s proposal is MUCH needed! The cost of childcare is crippling. We pay $72,000 per year for twin infants.” — Greg W. from Hyde Park, who pays $6,000 per month

“We pay $90 a day, 4 days a week. If our son is home sick, we still pay. This would be life-changing for us, especially if we are lucky enough to have another baby. While we are incredibly blessed with our son, the cost of daycare is equivalent to a second mortgage.” — Chris from Holden, who pays $1,500 per month

“I would love Senator Warren’s proposal, or something similar, to pass. We are having to take equity out of our home to pay for two kids in daycare. It is important that child care workers are paid a fair wage, but the current system is not sustainable for most people.” — Chris from Stoneham, who pays $3,700 per month

“Anything that can be done to curb these rising child care costs would be a welcome relief.” — Sean E. from Natick, who pays $4,700 per month

“While both my husband and I make good money, child care still takes over 12% of our pre-tax income. There aren’t many cheaper options, and long waiting lists make any comparison shopping a challenge. I work in healthcare and having a reliable daycare for the past few years has been essential to allow me to go to work. We feel lucky to have a spot in a great daycare (now pre-school and pre-K) for our child and that we are able to pay. However, we can’t reasonably afford a second child at these rates. I support the proposal. If you want a thriving, vibrant economy you need adults at work. In order for them to work, there needs to be affordable child care and affordable for those making less than $150,000 a year as a household.” — B. from Newton, who pays $2,210 per month (which will increase to $2,300 next year)

Advertisement:

“I am currently paying $16,000 per year in daycare/child care costs and that’s at only four days a week. As a single mother on a single income, this means I am unable to save money for my son for the future. I am lucky to have a stable, management-level corporate career but I still feel the financial burden of child care costs every day. I think Warren’s proposal is amazing — it would allow me to save money for my son’s future/college or have money for emergencies with my house, etc. ” — Jessica L. from Franklin, who pays $1,350 per month

“This would be absolutely life-changing for my family. We are going to welcome our second child in the summer, and I am facing the reality of spending literally 100% of my take-home pay (as a professional engineer) on child care for both children. My oldest son is a September baby, so I will have to wait an entire extra school year before he is eligible for public school. We made an intentional effort to time the birth of our second child for August, just so we would be eligible for public school one year sooner.” — Stefanie from Somerville, who pays $2,040 per month

“Paying for child care has been extremely stressful for my husband and I since we started our family. It keeps us from doing so many other things and we live paycheck to paycheck despite being contracted public workers for over a decade. If this plan passes it would relieve so much stress for my family and literally change our lives for the better, financially, physically, and mentally. ” Angela K. from North Andover, who pays $2,908 per month

Advertisement:

“Our daycare in Metrowest costs more than our mortgage, and it’s not even close. We’ve had to reduce our savings per month, reduce our 401k contributions, eliminate the savings for our children’s college funds, and put many other items on hold until the kids are out of daycare…just to pay for both our mortgage and our daycare. If this proposal goes through, we could finally start preparing for our future, our children’s future, and actually have money left over at the end of the month. It would change our lives.” — Eric J. of Framingham, who pays $3,935 per month

“We’re expecting our second child any day now. We currently have one child in daycare and we’re just skating by. However, we will not be able to afford the cost of care for two children. We’ve made the difficult decision that one of us is going to have to give up our career to take care of our children due to the extravagant expense of daycare. This is not an ideal situation either as our income will be cut in half. This proposal would be a godsend.” — Kristen from Weymouth, who pays $1,500 per month

“I was recently paying over $40,000 per year for two children in a center-based daycare program. They have a good program, and certainly are preparing my children for elementary school, but the costs are absurd. I support proposals for limiting and controlling costs for families, but I also know that the staff are not well compensated and this is very important to improve as well.” — Anonymous from Franklin, who pays $2,000 per month

Against the proposal

“Against it. The proposal does not fix the underlying issue. Increase child care tax credit. Those that pay more in child care receive a bigger tax credit.” — George from Boston, who pays $3,500 per month

Advertisement:

“Foolish, another way to pass along tax burdens. If you can’t afford to support your kids don’t look for another free federal ride. Where/ who do I contact to get my refund for my years of daycare expenses? Let’s offer them all free education and college as well.” Stephen S. from Watertown, who pays $1,800 per month

“Warren’s proposal is just completely unrealistic for daycares to operate on and pay their teachers fairly. My child is in daycare for more hours in the day than I’m at work. His daycare provides 2 meals and a snack for what I pay for. The teachers are engaged in caring for my child and teaching him. Warren’s proposal would jeopardize the level of care and safety for children.” — P.L. from Acton, who pays $2,080 per month

“Instead of just throwing entitlement spending at the problem, I’d prefer that she worked to understand the fundamental issues that make child care more expensive in this state than others to make it more affordable for everyone.” — Heath from Charlestown, who pays $3,300 per month

“People who have children should be responsible and fund the care of those children. My husband and I make decent incomes and therefore can afford daycare. Those who cannot should reconsider having children. Why do taxpayers need to foot the bill for others’ personal problems?” — Kat from Cohasset, who pays $1,400 per month

‘Sounds too good to be true’

“This sounds like a dream, but where is the funding coming from, and what does this do to the quality of child care and child care providers?” — Anonymous from Boston who pays $5,500 per month

Advertisement:

“Sounds too good to be true. Where will the money come from and how will it ensure appropriate pay for child care workers? Of course, I’d love to pay less! I just want to understand the details and also be sure the child care workers I trust with my child will be paid a living wage commensurate with their skills and experience.” — Tiffany K. from Boston, who pays $2,000 per month

“What Warren is proposing sounds great, but too good to be true. What is the catch? $200 per month is almost too drastic. I feel this is going to incentivize families to work less to stay under the $130k cap to get this significantly reduced cost. Will there be requirements that both parents need to work full time?” — Colleen from Westford, who pays $3,500 per month

“Yes, the price of child care feels ridiculous. You are basically paying college tuition prices for toddler care. And as a result of those prices, it is easy to see why families choose to have a parent stay home. I mean, at the prices we pay around Boston, if you have two kids in child care you need to make at least $70k in pre-tax income just to break even. So in that sense, the idea of capping the expense seems like a good idea. But, like many Warren proposals, I have concerns about the practicality. Daycares are already having a hard enough time keeping and retaining staff so how are they going to remain whole? Do we really think the companies that run these daycares are going to be ok with making less money? If there is a government subsidy who is paying for that? I have serious doubts.